effingham 217-342-2229 | godfrey (618) 300-8429
What to bring to Friendsgiving: BYOB guide by party type

The invite comes in. “Friendsgiving at our place! We’ve got the food, just bring something to drink.” 🍷

Figuring out what to bring to Friendsgiving shouldn’t be hard. Then you’re standing in front of 6,000 bottles wondering if wine is too boring, whether a 30-pack is too much, and whether anyone actually wants the flavored vodka you’ve been eyeing.

You’re not the only one. In a recent Napa Cellars survey reported by The Manual, nearly a quarter of Friendsgiving hosts said they handle the food and ask guests to bring their own drinks. So “what should I bring?” is officially the question of the season. Here’s the answer, matched to the kind of party you’re walking into.

The 5 golden rules of BYOB

Before we get to bottles, a few rules that make you the guest everyone wants back.

  1. Bring enough to share. BYOB at a party really means “bring your own, plus a little for the table.” Plan to cover yourself and at least one other person.
  2. Bring it ready to drink. Chill the white wine, bubbly and beer before you leave. The host’s fridge is already packed with turkey.
  3. Bring what was asked. If the host says “we need a red,” bring a red. If they say nothing, use the guide below.
  4. Leave it behind. Anything you open stays with the host. Taking half a bottle home is a no.
  5. Think about the drivers. Adding a zero-proof option is a small move people really notice.

What to bring to Friendsgiving, by party type

Friendsgiving isn’t always a big sit-down dinner anymore. The same survey found that about two-thirds of people now prefer a daytime get-together, with brunch and a late-afternoon “sip and graze” topping the list. So start with when the party is, then pick your bottle.

If the party is…Bring thisWhy it works
Brunch-givingA bottle of bubbly, or Malibu Pink for a pitcher of sangriaLight, bright and made for daytime
Sip and graze (late afternoon)Surfside Tea & Vodka 8-packGrab-and-go, no mixing, easy to share
Sit-down dinnerBeaujolais Nouveau or a pinot noirFruity reds get along with everything on the table
Game-day FriendsgivingKeystone Light 30-pack or Busch Latte 15-packCovers the whole crowd through four quarters
You’re the cocktail friendTito’s 1.75L plus mixers for a mule pitcherOne big bottle makes 20+ drinks
Dessert and nightcapsWoodford Reserve Double OakedA rich, sweet bourbon that loves pie
What to bring to Friendsgiving by party type: brunch, sip and graze, dinner, game day, cocktails and dessert

Brunch-giving: bring the bubbles 🥂

A morning or early afternoon party calls for drinks that won’t knock anyone out before noon. A dry sparkling wine works for mimosas or a toast on its own. Want to bring something more fun? Mix a quick Malibu Pink sangria at home and carry it over in a pitcher or a big mason jar.

Malibu Pink sangria (serves about 8): 1 cup Malibu Pink, one 750ml bottle of rosé or white wine, 2 cups pineapple juice and a bag of sliced fruit (oranges, strawberries, apples). Stir, chill and top with a splash of soda water right before serving.

Sip and graze: bring the easy grab

Charcuterie boards and people wandering around with a plate? This is canned cocktail territory. A Surfside Tea & Vodka variety 8-pack needs no ice bucket, no opener and no bartender. Toss it in the fridge and everybody can help themselves.

Sit-down dinner: bring a red (or a white)

If there’s a table, a turkey and a seating chart, wine is the classic move. Beaujolais Nouveau, the first French wine of the year, releases Thursday, Nov 19, and it’s practically made for Thanksgiving: light, fruity and great slightly chilled. Pinot noir is the other can’t-miss red. For a white, grab a crisp sauvignon blanc or an unoaked chardonnay.

Not sure which wine fits the menu? Tell our wine team what’s being served. With 500+ craft labels in the wine shop, they’ll point you to a bottle you’ll feel good about. Want to taste first? Our Copper Cane Wine Tasting is Monday, Nov 23, 5:30–7:00 PM at Top Shelf Effingham. Tickets are $10 and spots are limited, so ask any team member.

Game-day Friendsgiving: bring the cooler

Some Friendsgivings are really just football with a side of stuffing. Read the room and bring a Keystone Light 30-pack or a Busch Latte 15-pack. Value beer by the case is the easiest way to be a hero at a party with a TV on.

The cocktail friend: bring the big bottle

If your friends know you as “the one who makes drinks,” lean into it. Grab a Tito’s 1.75L and show up with a batch ready to pour.

Tito’s cranberry mule pitcher (serves about 10): 15 oz Tito’s Handmade Vodka, 2 cups cranberry juice, 4 cups ginger beer (add right before serving), the juice of 2 limes and a few rosemary sprigs. Serve over ice with fresh cranberries.

Tito's cranberry mule pitcher recipe to bring to Friendsgiving

For more batch ideas, see our Thanksgiving drinks for a crowd guide.

Dessert and nightcaps: bring the pie pairing

Pumpkin and pecan pie are begging for a bourbon on the side. Woodford Reserve Double Oaked is aged a second time in a heavily toasted barrel, which gives it deep caramel, vanilla and toasted-oak notes. Pour it neat next to dessert. The 375ml bottle is a perfect size to bring along.

How much should you bring?

A good rule: bring enough for yourself plus one more person for the length of the party. Most people have about one drink per hour, so for a four-hour Friendsgiving:

  • Coming solo: one bottle of wine (about five glasses) or a 6-pack
  • Coming as a couple: two bottles of wine, or a 12-pack plus a bottle of wine
  • Bringing a batch cocktail: one 750ml bottle of spirits makes about 17 drinks, so you’ve got the room covered

Hosting instead? Plug your guest count into our free party drink calculator.

Host gift vs. party drink: know the difference

Here’s a little etiquette secret. A bottle you hand the host as a gift isn’t the same as a bottle you bring for the party. If you want to say thank you, bring one nice bottle and say, “This one’s for you, save it for later.” Then bring your party drink separately.

Host gift vs. party drink: wine bottle with a Cheers gift tag for a BYOB Friendsgiving

Good host gifts that feel thoughtful, not random:

  • Casamigos Blanco: a smooth tequila for the friend who’s done with brown spirits for the year
  • Grey Goose: a classic for the espresso martini lover
  • Woodford Reserve Double Oaked: a dessert-ready bourbon in a gift-friendly size
  • The splurge: Orin Swift Mercury Head Cabernet Sauvignon, for the host who went all out (or the boss)

Add a bow, a handwritten tag, or ask our team about gift bags. Small touches make a big impression.

Don’t forget a zero-proof option

Somebody is driving. Somebody isn’t drinking this year. Bring something for them too. A bottle of sparkling cider, a few non-alcoholic beers, or the makings for a cranberry-rosemary spritz (cranberry juice, a splash of orange juice, sparkling water and a rosemary sprig) means everyone gets to be in the toast. We carry non-alcoholic beer, wine and spirits, so ask the team what’s on the shelf this week.

Beat the Turkey Wednesday rush

The Wednesday before Thanksgiving (Nov 25 this year) is one of the busiest days of the year at both stores. If your Friendsgiving is that weekend, shop early in the week for the best selection and a shorter wait. In a hurry? Pull through our drive-thru in Effingham or Godfrey. Skip the line, not the selection.

Show up with the right bottle

Knowing what to bring to Friendsgiving comes down to a few questions: what time is the party, what’s on the table, and who’s coming? Match your bottle to the vibe, bring enough to share, and throw in a zero-proof option for good measure. Still stuck? Stop in at Top Shelf Effingham or Godfrey, tell us about the party, and we’ll help you pick. That’s what we’re here for. Please drink responsibly and plan a safe ride home. Cheers! 🥃

Must be 21+ to purchase alcohol.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I bring to a BYOB Friendsgiving?

Match your drink to the party. Bring bubbly or a sangria for a brunch party, canned cocktails for a casual afternoon, wine for a sit-down dinner, a case of beer for a game-day crowd, and bourbon for dessert. Bring enough to share with at least one other person.

How much alcohol should I bring to Friendsgiving?

Plan on about one drink per hour for yourself plus one other guest. For a four-hour party, one bottle of wine or a 6-pack covers one person. A couple can bring two bottles of wine or a 12-pack and a bottle.

Is it rude to take my leftover alcohol home from a party?

Usually, yes. Anything you open at the party stays with the host. If you bring an unopened bottle as a gift, it’s theirs to keep too.

What’s a good wine to bring to Thanksgiving dinner?

Light, fruity reds like Beaujolais Nouveau or pinot noir and crisp whites like sauvignon blanc go with turkey and most sides. A dry sparkling wine is also a safe pick that works with almost anything.

What’s a good host gift for Friendsgiving?

One nice bottle with a note saying it’s for the host to enjoy later. Popular picks include a smooth blanco tequila, a premium vodka, a dessert-style bourbon or a special red wine.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This